LED tube replaces fluorescent

Due real Fluorescent lamp fire danger I have pretty much tried to get rid of potentially dangerous tradtional starters in the fuorescent lamps. So I replaced the starter with electronic safety model – if bulb does not start, it will stay off without heating. Or at least should. I got one Axxel S10 starter that did not always get the bulb started, and sometimes just stays on keeping the ends of the tube heated (which isthe thing that I was avoiding with electrical started) – and it seems that I was not the only person having this kind of problems with Axxel S10 starter.

So the next question was what to do? Is the fluoscent tube getting too old to start reliably, so I should change it? Maybe. Should I change the electronic starter Axel S10 to a safer model? Definately yes for safety.

But what if I would replace the fluorescent bulb with a modern LED tube. LED lighting is becoming popular all, and it seems that LED tubes designed to replace fluorescent tubes are now available at reasonable price. It would start immediately, which would be a big plus on toilet light. So I should get LED tube.

I did some reasearch where to get suitable LED tube, I needed one that fits on place of around 60 cm long 18W fluorescent tube on lamp that used tradtional magnetic ballast. Biltema had one suitable LED tube on their catalogue, but it was unavailable at the moment. I did some searching and found out that Motonet had two suitable models available for around 10 Euros listed available: Airam LED-loisteputki G13 9W 3000K 900lm and LED – loisteputki G13 9W 4000K 800lm 600mm.

At the shop I selected Airam LED-loisteputki G13 9W 3000K 900lm + sytytin (43-8936). It promised for 10W power intake it promises to puts out 900 lm light output. The tube has traditional G13 bases, has 26 mm diameter and 600 mm length. It came in this kind of package:

image

image

image

image

Here is the LED tube installed to the lamp.

image

As you can see it replaced the 600 mm 18W traditional LED tube nicely. I was wondering on how much light it puts out compared to old bulb. A quick testing with my multimeter that has built-in light meter gave good results: Same light output 500 Lux from arms lenght from lamp. The biggest difference on the light was that the ends that do not give out light are considerably longer on the LED tube than original fluorescent lamps, so you don’t get light all the way to the end on the lamp (was not a big issue on this lamp, looked still OK).

The package had also some instructions leaflet hat showed right usage on different kind of fluorescent lamps:

image

image

This LED tube seems to do well what is promised at least on my quick tests. It seems that LED technology has become a good alernative to old fluorescent bulb technology.

After this test I am ready to start replacing more of the fluorescent bulbs with LEDs.

Anyone have any recommendations for good replacement for compact fluorescent bulbs with G23 base to lamp that has two of them? It seems that bulbs with bigger G24 base are widely available (I have tested one G24 base LED bulb), but G23 base LED bulbs seem to be hard to find items. Any recommendation where to get them or does any manufacturer/shop has few free samples to test?

10 Comments

  1. Tomi Engdahl says:

    LED canopy shines bright at 143 lumens per watt
    http://www.edn.com/electronics-products/other/4442041/LED-canopy-shines-bright-at-143-lumens-per-watt?_mc=NL_EDN_EDT_EDN_analog_20160519&cid=NL_EDN_EDT_EDN_analog_20160519&elqTrackId=47c49622096348d380cf54852d649c07&elq=dd50de34821a4c2ab77f65c62a1c788d&elqaid=32319&elqat=1&elqCampaignId=28227

    An LED canopy and soffit luminaire from Cree, the CPY-20L produces 20,784 lumen with an efficacy of up to 143 lumens per watt at 5700K. The CPY-20L is the latest member of the CPY series, offering increased visibility to outperform existing LED and metal-halide options when used in fuel-pump canopies and other canopy/soffit applications. According to Cree, the CPY-20L’s high performance and efficiency allow store operators to lower operating costs, while providing safe and visually appealing lighting.

    All of the canopy and soffit luminaires in the CPY series are available with a CCT (correlated color temperature) of 4000K or 5700K and a choice of a flat or prismatic drop lens. Their slim, low-profile housing is constructed of rugged cast aluminum and can be surface-mounted from below the canopy deck or even pendant-mounted. An integrated driver within the canopy housing simplifies installation.

    Reply
  2. Tomi Engdahl says:

    LuxReview REVIEWED LED tubes
    http://luxreview.com/review/2016/05/led-tubes-to-replace-t8-fluorescent-lamps

    We bench test and rate the latest products from the major brands. Report by Lux technical editor Alan Tulla.

    If you are considering replacing your existing fluorescent lamps with LED tubes, you have two choices.

    If all you have to do is replace the lamp and starter (and nothing else), make sure that the LED tube complies with BS EN 62776:2015.

    There are thousands of T8 installations in the UK, some quite old and in need of refurbishment. There is also the increasing need to save energy. We tested LED tubes from 12 different suppliers. All the tubes were tested at the new Lighting Industry Association laboratories in Telford, UK.

    none of the LED tubes was totally correctly labelled as required by IEC 62776:2014.

    Note that these LED tubes are unlikely to be suitable for use in luminaires which are used for emergency lighting. Neither can they be dimmed.

    Most of the tubes we tested had fixed end caps but some were rotatable. This means that the light emitted can be angled to direct it where you most want it. I.e. the LEDs do not simply point straight down.

    The full title of BS EN 62776:2015 is “Double-capped LED lamps designed to retrofit linear fluorescent lamps. Safety specifications”. It runs to 34 pages of safety tests because there is a lot to consider.

    If your fluorescent lamp has an electronic ballast, you only need to swap the lamps. However, not all LED tubes are suitable for all HF ballasts. Some manufacturers, supply a ballast compatibility table.

    If the fluorescent lamp has a magnetic or wire-wound ballast you will also need to replace the starter canister. No other rewiring should be required.

    High power LEDs can be more glaring than a T8 lamp. If you think glare may be an issue, compare two luminaires side by side or run a glare calculation.

    Colour rendering
    It’s very easy to achieve high efficiency in terms of lumens per watt if you aren’t concerned about colour rendering. Any CRI greater than 80 should be OK for most applications.

    Reply
  3. Tomi Engdahl says:

    LED floodlights meet diverse market needs
    http://www.edn.com/electronics-products/other/4442723/LED-floodlights-meet-diverse-market-needs?_mc=NL_EDN_EDT_EDN_productsandtools_20160926&cid=NL_EDN_EDT_EDN_productsandtools_20160926&elqTrackId=a9e6155a2d8b4e77a21990fb8a81e832&elq=9534f765b0674bdf97094bb2007384f3&elqaid=34026&elqat=1&elqCampaignId=29750

    Eaton has expanded its Lumark Night Falcon LED floodlight series with both large and small models to replace HID (high intensity discharge) lamps rated from 70 W to 1000 W in a broad range of commercial and industrial applications. Furthermore, the Night Falcon luminaires provide greater than 75% savings in energy and maintenance costs.

    http://www.cooperindustries.com/content/public/en/lighting/resources/LightingStories/The-Lumark-Night-Falcon.html

    Reply
  4. Tomi Engdahl says:

    Led Tube T8 Retrofit: Single-Ended vs. Double-Ended
    https://www.eeweb.com/electronics-forum/led-tube-t8-retrofit-single-ended-vs.-double-ended

    In order to reduce material and labor costs, a preferred way of replacing inefficient 32W T8 lamps is by removing them and installing ~17W LED tubes. These LEDs can come in several configurations.

    The first configuration involves simply replacing the tube and reusing the existing electronic ballast. In this case initial manual labor is involved but the ballast would still require maintenance after its rated hours

    The second configuration is single-ended power and using an external ballast/driver.

    A third configuration is single-ended power with no ballast needed.

    Existing fluorescent lamps are typically double-ended power, meaning one side of the feed is hot and the other side neutral.

    I have exactly the same questions. Apparently it has been more difficult to get the dual ended designs to pass UL and FCC. It may require extra circuitry for shielding or safety. These devices are now on the market and can be purchases from Amazon, made by Hyperikon. They make both single end powered and dual end powered T8 LED bulbs. The dual end powered devices are $1.5 more per bulb.

    Michele Cecchettini
    (+1), 1 month ago

    Score: 1

    We are lighting equipment manufacturer, of course the following is our own opinion: we believe that double-ended is better because its inherent safety. Moreover, we agree with previous post stating that replacing old neon is easier.

    Reply
  5. Tomi Engdahl says:

    The new standard accelerates the LED light market
    21.1.2015 8:27

    LED lighting tubes are the first, and so far, the only LED lamp that has received an international harmonized standard (EN 62776).

    Standardization makes it possible to produce LED light tubes compatible with traditional T8 fluorescent tubes. In addition, the standard defines the characteristics of the LED light tube so that they are always compatible with each other.

    With the new standard, the old fluorescent lamp can replace the LED tube with the fluorescent tube and in the future, this LED light tube can be replaced with another standard LED light tube.

    The standard makes LED lighting tubes easier and safer so that LED light tubes can be expected to become more commonly replaced by fluorescent tubes.

    The Valtavalo G3 + LED light tube, launched last autumn, is one of the first LED-light tubes manufactured according to the harmonized standard.

    Source: https://valtavalo.fi/tiedotteet/uusi-standardi-vauhdittaa-led-valoputkimarkkinaa/

    Reply
  6. Tomi Engdahl says:

    Retrofit LED tubes
    Safety requirements under the new standard IEC 62776
    http://www.esti.admin.ch/files/aktuell/2015-02_retrofit-led.e.pdf

    Requirements for retrofit LED tubes according to the standard IEC 62776

    ■ Correct marking on the LED tube, correct installation and operating instructions
    ■ Safe interchangeability in any FL fixtures
    ■ Secured against falling out
    ■ Maximum temperatures in operation
    ■ Protection during inserting and removing
    ■Protection against unintended contact with live parts
    ■ Construction
    ■ Heat resistance
    ■ Compliance with photobiological safety

    Requirements for marketing according to NEV
    ■ LED tubes that carry voltage between the two caps are still prohibited. At least basic insulation must be assured.
    ■LED tubes which comply with the standard IEC 62776 are permitted in Switzerland, with one exception: it is prohibited to market LED tubes that have an open/blank side

    Reply
  7. Tomi Engdahl says:

    The latest safety standard for LED tubes: what you need to know
    http://luxreview.com/article/2015/06/a-new-standard-for-led-tubes

    If you are thinking of replacing a fluorescent lamp with an LED tube, you should be aware of an important new safety standard introduced by the IEC (International Electrotechnical Commission) in December 2014. It’s called IEC 62776 and it covers safety specifications for double-capped LED tubes.

    The standard does not apply to all retrofit LED tubes; only those where the tube is powered by the existing control gear, either electronic or magnetic, so no internal modification of the luminaire is required (except replacing the glow starter by a ‘dummy’ to complete the circuit, which is not considered a modification under this standard).

    Generally, retrofit LED tubes come in two types: those where no modification to the luminaire is required (where IEC 62776 applies) and the more common type where some rewiring or bypassing of the existing control gear is needed.

    In the latter, you rewire the luminaire so that the incoming mains goes straight to the lamp caps. Whether or not this is a good idea is a hotly disputed topic in the lighting world, and there is currently no specific safety standard for these lamps. However, there is general agreement among European laboratories that tests for these lamps should apply the appropriate aspects from related safety standards such as 60598, 61347 and 62031 together with a risk assessment and a detailed review of the modification instructions supplied.

    Currently, most of the major lamp manufacturers build their LED tubes to meet the new IEC 62776 standard, but you should always check with your supplier.

    Remember that IEC 62776 (and the other standards mentioned above) are about safety.

    Reply
  8. Tomi Engdahl says:

    Retail abandons CMH lamps in favor of flexible solid-state lighting (MAGAZINE)
    http://www.ledsmagazine.com/articles/print/volume-13/issue-5/features/retail/retail-abandons-cmh-lamps-in-favor-of-flexible-solid-state-lighting.html?cmpid=enl_leds_architecturalillumination_2017-06-26

    Retail shops, with their long operating hours, have been among the earliest adopters of LED-based solid-state lighting (SSL) due to its high energy efficiency. Retail lighting is on anywhere from 12 to 24 hours per day, so the 80% improvement in energy efficiency for SSL pays off quickly. High-quality light and good lighting design are essential to attractive presentation of merchandise – and, therefore, to a store’s success. Energy-efficient lighting is of no benefit to store owners if their merchandise appears dull and colorless. Retailers have thus helped to push the SSL industry to deliver higher quality of light with good color rendering and a broad range of color temperatures.

    Legacy lamps and narrow beams

    One area, however, where retailers have been reluctant to move away from conventional lighting technology is in the use of ceramic-discharge metal-halide (CDM) or ceramic-metal-halide (CMH) lamps. They produce very high-quality light, have good light maintenance, and offer greater longevity relative to halogen lamps, which balances their relatively higher cost. Their greatest competitive advantage over high-quality SSL has been their ability to produce high flux density in a narrow beam or high center beam candle power (CBCP).

    CDM lamps used in spot, track, and down lighting are central to the dramatic illumination needed for high-contrast lighting design, including the ability to illuminate a small area with high flux levels to attract customer attention to important merchandise displays. For example, CDM PAR30 lamps are generally offered in 35-39W and 70W power consumption variants. The CDM 39W PAR30 lamp has a spot beam spread of 10~15° with an initial lumen output of around 2400 lm. This lamp has a CBCP of 30,000~40,000 cd. CDM 70W PAR30 lamps have spot beam spreads of 10~15° with an initial lumen output of around 4800 lm and a CBCP of 40,000~60,000 cd.

    Having met retailers’ demand for both higher lumen output levels and higher quality of light, SSL source manufacturers are now challenged to reproduce in LED-based light sources the high narrow-beam flux density delivered by CDM lamps

    Achieving this goal will allow SSL to replace CDM lamps in track, spot, and down lights, as well as other key lighting applications.

    Such high-lumen-density COBs enable luminaire and solid-state lamp OEMs to drop a component into their existing spot, track, and down light luminaire designs or replacement lamps. These new light sources can deliver a shaped beam from 10° narrow spots for intense light to 25° narrow flood beam spread for accent and down lighting applications while still maintaining small form factors for luminaire OEM designs or PAR30 and PAR38 lamps.

    The ultrahigh-density COB arrays can be provided in a range of standard light-emitting surface (LES) diameters such as 6, 9, 11, and 14 mm, which again simplifies the integration of these CDM replacement light sources into existing designs. SSL lamp and luminaire OEMs can use their existing ecosystems for optics and connectors, while delivering new bulbs and fixtures with higher lumen output and increased CBCP to their customers.

    Flexibility in color quality

    Phasing out the last CDM lamps offers retailers benefits beyond cost, quality of light, and flexible lighting design attributes. It allows them to simplify their entire operation, controlling light as never before. They won’t need a mixture of lighting technologies, separate maintenance schedules for conventional and SSL technologies, or a replacement lamp inventory

    Reply

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*

*