Unshielded RCA cable is bad design

Here is a bit long article about HIFI system interconnect cables. There are pages promoting use of different unshielded cable constructions for HIFI systems interconnections. But the truth is that unshielded RCA cable is bad design and should be avoided. This article tells the truth about unshielded RCA cables, why they are bad and how many pages promoting them are wrong.

Nearly any signal that uses RCA connectors are considered line level. These are very weak signals (0.1-2V) and will pick up noise easily (unbalanced, output impedance can be up to 5000 ohms). RCA connectors are also used to carry sometimes phono signals, those are even weaker and will pick up noise even more easily than line level signals.

Interconnects with RCA plugs should be made with coax cable or shielded twisted pair cable to work well. Typically interconnects with RCA plugs are made with coax cable. The coax encases the signal wire in a pipe that protects it from interference.

1core-sh

Unshielded cable, like ordinary speaker wire or CAT5 UTP, is unsuitable cable for RCA interconnections. It will pick up noise very easily. This noise is usually heard as  a low level fuzz (less than totally silent background)  and obvious hum.

Your speaker level wires (with about 10-30 volts signal typically 8 ohm load impedance and fractions of ohms amplifier output) are much less sensitive to radiated noise than the RCA signal wires. That’s why they can live well without shielding.

Line level cables use considerably lower signal voltages and very much higher impedance, so they pick up noise more easily. For interconnects shielded construction is the way to go for line level RCA interconnects. Shielding on unbalanced interconnects does make a big difference in the background noise level.

Unshielded twisted pair cable, like CAT5 networking cable, is bad idea for RCA interconnects. It is true that due to its characteristic CAT5 and similar have low capacitance, but that’s where the good news end.

utp

You might have read that that UTP cable construction has good noise rejection characteristics and can carry signals well without shielding. CAT5 cables used in a computer network system are renowned for their ability to reject unwanted noises. It is true that twisted pair geometry works for the phone companies who run miles of cable and for Ethernet LANs very well without noise problems. Unshielded twisted pair works and rejects noise in those applications well because it is used in them to carry balanced signals.

Cat 5 and similar unshielded twisted pair (UTP) cables only work effectively when run as balanced lines where there are common-mode noise rejection properties built into the system. That common mode rejection is easily accomplished when the receiving circuit is passive (headphones or loudspeaker), transformer coupled, isolated and battery operated, or otherwise not referenced in any way to the transmitting-circuit common (either capacitively or resistively connected). For best performance the signal signal sending end should have same impedance from both signal wires to ground.

When you wire unshielded twisted pair to unbalanced signal source and receiver RCA connectors, most of the good properties of the UTP cable noise rejection are lost.  Unbalanced RCA interfaces found in normal HIFI equipment do not have common-mode noise rejection properties. The coupled noise will get to the signal on the cable. Therefore UTP is not effective for unbalanced home/consumer applications.Read Cat5 cable VS RCA cable for car stereo use article if you want to see test results.

There are also special unshielded braided unshielded cable construction made for HIFI interconnects. Those suffer from the same basic problems as the unshielded twisted pair cables, although some designs might offer a slightly better noise rejection characteristics than twisted pair. But they are still poorly shielded and should be avoided.

4play_plugs

(image from 4-Play)

Unshielded unbalanced cables are very sensitive to capacitive coupling especially when circuit impedance is high (impedance mostly determined by signal source output impedance in HIFI systems). For example power cords radiate a magnetic field and an electric field that is prone to carrying the interference that rides on all AC power lines to some extent. Shielding is an essential part of a proper RCA audio cable.  It is true that shielded cable has higher total cable capacitance than otherwise similar unshielded cable, but that’s the price you have to pay for the noise free sound.

The cable capacitance can affect the sound going through the cable. The most typical effect is that the cable capacitance together with signal source output impedance forms a low pass filter that more or less attenuates the highest frequencies. How much cable capacitance effect depends very much on the signal source output impedance (output impedance is typically in 30 ohms to 5000 ohms range, much bigger variation range than in capacitance of different audio cable types). If the signal source badly engineered, then the cable capacitance affects the signal source output driver amplifier stability, causing distortion and risk of oscillation at high cable capacitance. A well designed HIFIi equipment should be designed to cope with the normal cable capacitance. If the capacitance of normal shielded cable has considerable effect on the sound you get, there is something wrong with your signal source!

Some HIFI manufacturers (especially cable manufacturers that make such cables) say that unshielded unbalanced cables generally sound better than shielded (if your area does not have a lot of RF energy). If you are so lucky that you don’t have such noise sources nearby and like playing then you can try unshielded cable if you wish. Anyways in today’s high tech world  it is hard to find places without much RF energy nearby because for example cellular phones are very common and cause lots of noise if placed nearby unshielded cable. All well designed interconnects sound identical. Some interconnects are badly designed and do indeed sound different.

In today’s modern world you should always use shielded RCA cable. A coaxial design with a braided mesh shield is a good choice and braid shielded twisted pair is also good for making RCA cables. All well designed interconnects sound identical. Some interconnects are badly designed and do indeed sound different. Unshielded RCA cables are conceptually bad designs and should be avoided. Unshielded cables are OK only for applications that use balanced signals (professional audio), but even in those applications using shielded cables is the preferred.

115 Comments

  1. SoBizarre says:
    It’s not always that simple. There are equipment combinations which REQUIRE twisted pair RCA. Here’s explanation:

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QOagVDZLQnA

    Reply
    • tomi says:
      The video you pointed to and I can agree things said on this.

      In case the amplifier has differential RCA inputs (that are pretty rare), using twisted pair cabling with then would be better than coaxial cable. But again here shielding would be beneficial: properly shielded twisted pair is better than unshielded twisted pair.

      Unbalanced RCA interfaces found in normal HIFI equipment do not have common-mode noise rejection properties, and using unshielded twisted pair cable with gives poor performance – said on my original article and on the video.

      This was my short comment. I might some later time write some longer comment on this on my blog…

      Reply
  2. Twisted pair RCA cables again « Tomi Engdahl’s ePanorama blog says:
    [...] pair RCA cables again I wrote few years ago blog article Unshielded RCA cable is bad design. I just received yesterday a comment on it: “It’s not always that simple. There are [...]
    Reply
  3. atv motocross helmets says:
    In which otherwise may possibly possibly any individual acquire that sort of info in these an excellent indicates of producing?
    Reply
  4. Graham Knopf says:
    I have to show my thanks to the writer for rescuing me from this type of difficulty. Because of scouting throughout the world-wide-web and getting suggestions that were not productive, I was thinking my life was over. Existing without the answers to the problems you’ve resolved by means of this short post is a critical case, as well as the ones which may have in a negative way affected my entire career if I hadn’t discovered your blog. Your good talents and kindness in touching all the pieces was crucial. I am not sure what I would have done if I had not encountered such a point like this. I’m able to at this time relish my future. Thanks for your time very much for your high quality and result oriented help. I will not think twice to recommend your web page to anyone who ought to have support on this issue.
    Reply
  5. Ruthie Huhtasaari says:
    There are several Recruiting Agents who have a pool of financial experts. These experts not only stay-put on the laws in the financial practices, but also preserve track of all of the capacity changes that take place inside financial vineyard.
    Reply
  6. John Michael says:
    for those of us who cannot control anger, i think that anger management should be a reuirement to have a quality life;;
    Reply
  7. Galinka says:
    ohh yess >< a mp3/flac release would be really awesome
    Reply
  8. Galinka says:
    i don’t have factime audio icon in my iphone 5.how to fix this problem
    Reply

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*

*